Customer Reviews

Fort Branch, IN

Jon Schrage
Jon Schrage
15:01 11 Jul 18
I love the pizza here. Make sure that you order one with the sweet red peppers... They are amazing.
Dan Knox
Dan Knox
09:32 06 Jul 18
The best lunch pizza buffet ever!! Pizza was fresh, delicious and fast service!! Great atmosphere too. When you go try the the root beer in the barrel! The best root beer you will have.
Kimberley Phillippe
Kimberley Phillippe
14:57 28 Jun 18
Amazing pizzas. We had a small combination pizza, 2 salad bars and 2 drinks for about $20.
April Helfert
April Helfert
18:44 12 Jun 18
Great pizza and service. I love that you have Diet Mt. Dew
Shannyn Richardville
Shannyn Richardville
14:27 12 Jun 18
The people there are super. The food is amazing and worth the money. Would very much recommend this place to eat at.
Kathy Liden
Kathy Liden
12:26 03 Jun 18
Best pizza in this area. Hate the wait on the line though, but it's worth it Strombolis are spectacular, I tried other one down the road from them and was sick for a week. Wont leave Sandys again
Mark Schmitz
Mark Schmitz
12:41 26 May 18
Local favorite. Great atmosphere. Good pizza etc
Daniel Sigler
Daniel Sigler
01:52 14 May 18
Best pizza in the area with fun & homey decor. If you are in the area a must go.
Brenna Kelley
Brenna Kelley
22:27 31 Mar 18
We got there with only an hour left for the buffet and 4 hungry girls. They asked what the girls wanted and made it for them. Salad bar was nice with fresh veggies.
Christopher Lance Shell
Christopher Lance Shell
22:38 05 Mar 18
I think their crust could be better but their toppings are awesome. They have a salad bar thats included as well as on tap root beer and ice cream. And love the atmosphere
Joey Brines
Joey Brines
00:33 24 Feb 18
The food and the service was great. Great atmosphere.
Benjamin Bush
Benjamin Bush
17:53 14 Feb 18
Pizza is awesome. The fact that they don't keep fresh pizzas coming out on the buffet makes it not worth the drive for us. I understand food cost but gas is expensive and time is priceless. I heard about there pizza a lot. Finally had it for lunch 4 days in two weeks. The Root beer is sooo good tho
Fiona Jarvis
Fiona Jarvis
15:33 31 Dec 17
Great service and best pizza ! I Always enjoy coming here with family when i visit for the holidays .
Jennifer Wilder
Jennifer Wilder
01:00 31 Dec 17
Best pizza in the Tri-State area! We eat here every time we visit our family in Owensville. The inside is cute with old signs and lots of broken clocks. We love the crust and the sweet red peppers are delicious!
Chris Wilkerson
Chris Wilkerson
15:17 17 Dec 17
Pizza was good and the staff was friendly. Takes a little while to get your food but worth the wait.
Nicole Stevenson
Nicole Stevenson
22:44 22 Sep 17
The atmosphere is great and food I'd phenomenal! Would definitely recommend this nice down home pizza joint!
Revive Harpers
Revive Harpers
00:03 21 Sep 17
I always enjoy going to Sandy's. They have a great atmosphere. They also make some of the best pizza's and strom's in my area.
Nathan Pfeffer
Nathan Pfeffer
17:27 05 Sep 17
Nice local restaurant with a good atmosphere and delicious pizza.
Matthew Bartsch
Matthew Bartsch
20:50 23 Aug 17
Have ate here several times and it is always a clean fun environment. Love all the nostalgia hanging all over the place and of course the pizza pies and other food are the best around. Keep up the great food!!
Theresa Bunch
Theresa Bunch
23:04 16 Jul 17
Fun family pizza place. Great buffet, we will definitely be stopping in on our next trip to the area.
Jon Baker
Jon Baker
17:26 14 Jul 17
Always love the buffet, real pizza just like you would order, not cheap skimpy versions
Eric Thompson
Eric Thompson
23:01 06 Jul 17
Helpful staff with unique pizza. They will make whatever you would like on buffet nights. Quality ingredients.
Chris Overton
Chris Overton
22:21 04 Jul 17
Best pizza ever. Roasted red peppers are great. My favorite pizza on the planet.
Keevin Biggs
Keevin Biggs
04:07 31 Mar 17
Nice Local Pizza Place--Always very busy--they have buffets, and you can order from a large menu, along with free refills and ice cream. It is a nearby, very good local pizza place. Don't miss their pizza with the cherry peppers!
Allen E
Allen E
20:49 11 Mar 17
Today I tried the Sunday buffet. Great ice cream and selection of pizza. I also enjoyed the root beer that they had on tap. Though the food was good I did have a issue locating the correct public entrance to the building. After that I did not find a sign posted stating if I should wait to be seated or even be greeted before begining the buffet. Once I approached a employee they were friendly and took care of me. I enjoyed the atmosphere with multiple TV's that provided different sport stations. I'd suggest this local brand over a national chain.
bryan holzappel
bryan holzappel
22:55 06 Mar 17
Good pizza! Love the sweet red peppers! The root beer here is wonderful!
Brian Mitchell
Brian Mitchell
18:13 26 Feb 17
Amazing pizza. Sausage and sweet red peppers is probably my favorite. Kind staff. Buffet style service with a friendly happy attitude. Lots of neat stuff to look at in this place.
See All Reviews Write a review

Princeton, IN

Nick Hurter
Nick Hurter
14:09 05 Jul 18
wow! wished we lived closer because it's that good
Trudy McRoberts
Trudy McRoberts
23:41 13 Aug 17
Every time we are heading to Princeton from Huntingburg we just gotta have your pizza. Love Love it
Delaney Welch
Delaney Welch
03:03 16 Jul 17
Being pregnant, wanting what I want is kind of something that happens. I decided I wanted a Stromboli, and was set to get it. It was about 9pm, I called & was told that they would be open until ten for customers, and 11 for businesses. I tried to call at about 9:20 and didn't get an answer. I ended up driving there, pulled in with an open sign. I parked and walked to the front and they had shut all of the lights off. It was about 935. The young lady in management that night, Kayla, opened the door and told us they had to close due to labor costs and not getting enough business that night. I completely understood, and explained to her I had called and was told they would be open until 10 for customers and 11 for business. She asked what we were wanting, I told her two Stromboli's. She very kindly told us she would make them for us, and to come inside and we could pay and get the food. I was very impressed with the service and she was extremely kind about the situation. Thank you, Sandy's Princeton! We will be back again! And as for Kayla, I was told she was new to management, and I am very impressed with the was she handled that situation. Well trained and very sweet.
Neil Williams
Neil Williams
23:04 14 Jul 17
They are my go to pizza on Monday and Tuesday and a huge plus is they deliver to Oakland city!! They make a good solid pie and there crust holds up good to multiple toppings that would "break" a wimpy crust. It's been three weeks since my first review tonight got the large pie double cheese, double pepperoni, mushrooms and extra sauce ( if a place has a great tasting sauce always get double sauce it helps carry all the flavors, also makes for the best day after pizza because all the sauce doesn't " dissappear" into the crust had it cooked well done. Dang good pie. Tonight also got the 12" grinder for the first time and it's a darn good sandwich but I would make it with cheese on the bottom and top to help keep all the toppings encased in that fantastic dairy gooeyness because they really load this mother down. Good quality ingredients, fast delivery, not skimping on the toppings and most importantly their employees generally seem to be positive pizza people.
Maxwell Hammond
Maxwell Hammond
01:51 11 Jun 17
The owner is a fantastic man and you'll receive fantastic service. The pizza is probably good too. Haven't had it yet, had to write this review first. Yeah the service is that fantastic. EDIT: The pizza is fantastic too.
Stephanie Besing
Stephanie Besing
21:22 07 Apr 17
Better than what you get at the original Sandy's!!
David Autumn Langham
David Autumn Langham
02:26 08 Feb 17
The Pizza is awesome, at a decent price. You have to try the 36 inch pizza!!
Matt Hitchcock
Matt Hitchcock
00:18 19 Jul 16
Just a little bit ago I received a call from the store manager Julia, at Sandy's Pizza in Princeton, she called to apologize for not returning any of my calls. She explained the new procedures they are having to do with the new accountant and how instead of taking a few hours to get an answer it now can take up to a few days. All is forgiven, as I said before this was never about the quality of the food it all had to do with how I was treated by the store manager. The discrepancy had been taken care of already so Julia, didn't have to call but she did and for that reason I will continue to do business at Sandy's Pizza!!!
See All Reviews Write a review

 

Google Rating
4.2

Sandy's Pizza

609 South Main Street
Fort Branch, Indiana
Phone: (812) 753-3972
Map & Directions »

No Personal Checks Accepted

Hours

Mon 4:00pm-10:00pm
Tues-Thurs 10:30am-10:00pm
Fri-Sat 10:30am-11:00pm
Sun 10:30am-10:00pm

Google Rating
3.9

Sandy's Pizza

111 East Broadway
Princeton, Indiana
Phone: (812) 635-9128
Map & Directions »

No Personal Checks Accepted

New Hours!

Mon 4pm-9pm
Tues-Thurs 10am-9pm
Fri 10am-10pm
Sat 4pm-10pm
Sun 4pm-9pm

Suggestions & Comments

Please call Kaley Tooley, General Manager, at 812-677-1755 if you have any suggestions, comments, or complaints.

We aim for 100% customer satisfaction!

Customer Reviews

See what others are saying about us, or rate us and share your experience.

Fundraisers

Wanna make some dough? Learn about our fundraising opportunities.

Follow Us

Have a great time at Sandy's Pizza? Share your experience on Facebook.